First and foremost, the IRS training manual tells its auditors that they are examining you, not just your tax return.
The auditor wants to see how you match up with the income reported on your return -- "economic reality" in IRS-speak. If your business is audited, the IRS will likely investigate these issues:
- Did you report all of your business sales or receipts? If you "forgot" to report significant business income -- $10,000 or more -- strongly consider hiring a tax pro to handle the audit. Remove yourself from the process altogether. If the auditor finds evidence of large amounts of unreported income, and it looks intentional, he may call in the IRS criminal investigation team. However, if there is any kind of halfway plausible explanation ("someone must have forgotten to record September's sales"), then don't worry about jail. The auditor will probably just assess the additional tax you should have paid in the first place, plus interest and a 20% penalty.
- Did you write off personal living costs as business expenses? Let's face it, every small-time operator has claimed a personal expense as a business one. For little things, such as a few personal long-distance calls on the business telephone line, the IRS won't get too excited. But if you deducted $2,000 in repairs on your motor home during a trip to Yellowstone, an auditor may figure this out by looking at your receipts and disallow it, with penalty added.
- Does your lifestyle square with your reported income? An auditor sizes you up for dress style, jewelry, car and furnishings in your home or office if given a chance to make these observations. Someone who looks like a Vegas high roller, with a tax return of a missionary, will cause any auditor to dig deeper.
- Did you take cash or otherwise divert income into your own pocket without declaring it? Expect the auditor to suspect skimming if your business handles a lot of cash.
- Did you write off personal auto expenses as business? Personal use of your business-deducted set of wheels is so common that auditors expect to find it. That doesn't mean they will accept it, however. Auditors don't believe you use your one-and-only auto 100% for business and never to run to the grocery store or the dentist. If you operate your car for both business and pleasure and claim a high percentage of business usage, keep good records (preferably a mileage log).
- Did you claim personal entertainment, meals or vacation costs as business expenses? Travel and entertainment business expenses are another area where the IRS knows it can strike gold. Document all travel and entertainment deductions. Taking buddies to the ball game and calling it business won't fly if you can't explain the business relationship in a credible fashion.
- If you have employees, are you filing payroll tax returns and making tax deposits? Employment taxes are a routine part of every audit of a small enterprise.
- And last but not least, if you hire people you call "independent contractors," are they really employees? The IRS routinely conducts audits of businesses that hire independent contractors because of the tax savings associated with hiring contractors instead of employees.
This list is by no means complete. These are just the most likely things an IRS auditor looks for.