Get the most out of your Inc. online experience by registering and joining the Inc. community today. Get access to all Inc.com content and priority invites to free Inc. networking events in your area.

Login using:


Or login directly through Inc.com

Finding Value In A Steamy Market

Amid a blistering four-month rally, most value stocks have become overvalued. It's time to dig deeper.

 

During the rapacious three-year bear market, stock investors would have preserved more of their capital by holding value stocks. Now that the bulls are back in charge in 2003, growth stock returns have trounced those of their value cousins 18.6%-to-12.7% year-to-date, according to respective Dow Jones Growth and Value style indexes.

Click here to download our special report, Forbes Adviser Favorites: 10 Stocks for the Summer of 2003.
All stocks--growth and value--have enjoyed healthy appreciation and have become quite expensive relative to earnings. The price-to-earnings ratio of the S&P 500 is now at 32; the P/E ratio of the Dow is greater than 29. Suddenly stocks are looking overvalued. We queried some of the best-performing value hunters among newsletter editors to learn if they were finding undervalued prospects in today's market.

John Buckingham is the editor of the Laguna Beach, Calif.-based Prudent Speculator, the No. 1 ranked newsletter according to The Hulbert Financial Digest. He manages a portfolio of more than 200 value stocks for the newsletter, as well as the Al Frank Fund , which is up 30.5% year-to-date. Home builders have been Buckingham's favorite stocks and best performers over the last two years, but most of the names he holds are above his recommended buy prices. One holdout, still a value according to Buckingham: D.R. Horton, which sports a P/E ratio of 9.

David Fried's Buyback Letter uncovers value by buying shares of companies that are repurchasing their own stock. Gains have amounted to 166% over the last seven years. Click here to get his July picks.

Not all technology names have become ridiculously expensive, Buckingham says. He recommends buying three moneylosing stocks that trade at or close to book value: networker 3Com, Dutch Internet company Via Net.Works and semiconductor maker Integrated Device Technology. Buckingham is also finding value in some transportation companies, such as CSX, which has a P/E of 15, and ocean shipper Sea Containers, which trades for 40% of book value and has a P/E of 6. Both companies stand to gain business if manufacturing activity picks up.

George Putnam of The Turnaround Letter is putting his money on Kohlberg Kravis & Roberts holding Primedia, a magazine conglomerate which once sold for as much as $34 per share but now trades for one-tenth of that price. Primedia has a price-to-sales ratio of less than 0.6; according to Putnam, its management and balance sheet have been overhauled.

For Kelley Wright, editor of Investment Quality Trends, the hallmark of value lies in rich dividend yields. As share prices appreciate in value, the dividend yield declines, and the stock becomes overvalued and ripe for selling. Wright publishes a list of "undervalued" stocks with dividend yields in the high end of their historic range, which he advises subscribers to buy. Included in his list are Altria, which yields 5.5%; Electronic Data Systems, with a 2.7% yield; and FleetBoston Financial, with a 4.5% yield.

Yield also figures prominently as a measure of value in the fixed-income market for Richard Lehmann, editor of the Forbes/Lehmann Income Securities Investor. Lehmann enjoyed tremendous gains over the last year by picking up distressed energy and telecom debt at huge discounts with yields upwards of 20%. As the prospects for those companies' survivability improved, so did the price of the debt. Now with interest rates heading higher and institutions shifting more money into stocks, Lehmann says to seek out high-yielding convertible bonds and preferreds, which pay decent income and have the potential to participate in the appreciation of equities.

Forbes Gurus' buy list, "Ten Stocks for the Summer of 2003," is already up nearly 15%. To download the picks, sign up for Forbes FREE Investment Guru Weekly E-mail.

Lehmann advises buying the 6% convertibles maturing in September 2009 from Level 3 Communications for a 9.5% yield. Among convertible preferreds, Lehmann recommends the 9.5% issue from TECO Energy for a 12.7% yield, as well as the Motorola 7% issue, which now yields 11.6%.

Send comments and questions to investingnewsletters@forbes.net.

More Newsletter Watch Columns

Learn more/subscribe to Forbes Newsletters.

Copyright © 2003 Forbes.com