Whole Foods to Chobani: Please Leave
Here we've got one outstanding entrepreneur selling his product to a public company run by another crazily successful entrepreneur. Both entrepreneurs care about healthy food, and they're both supporting another large community of entrepreneurs--dairy farmers. And it looks like it's going to be quite a mess.
According to a story in the Wall Street Journal, Whole Foods Market, still run by co-founder and co-CEO John Mackey, has said it will no longer be selling Chobani yogurt as of 2015. Chobani is owned and operated by Hamdi Ulukaya, a Turkish immigrant and entrepreneur who is credited with turning struggling areas of upstate New York into a veritable yogurt nirvana.
In a statement released by Chobani, Ulukaya said, "Though we have very limited distribution within Whole Foods, they have been an important partner of ours over the years," and added, "We hope to continue our partnership moving forward."
Whole Foods is reportedly dropping Chobani because it wants to make room on its shelves for products from smaller producers that either do not contain genetically modified organisms or that clearly label ingredients that are genetically modified. While Chobani markets its yogurt as "Nothing but good," there have been complaints that some of the farmers who sell milk to Chobani give their cows genetically modified feed.
In the past, when asked why Chobani yogurt isn't non-GMO or organic, Ulukaya has generally demurred on two counts: price and community. It's important to him, he has said, that Chobani remain accessible to a mass audience, which he says makes organic ingredients too costly. And he says he's loyal to the farmers who helped him build his business, and doesn't want to either meddle in their livelihoods or cut them off.
Whole Foods also said it wants to be able to carry more niche yogurts and those exclusive to Whole Foods, implying that it will leave the door open to the small local producers it has often championed. For now, Whole Foods is still carrying Fage, another Greek-style yogurt that is not GMO-free and also not labeled as such. But Fage doesn't have nearly the distribution that Chobani does.
While Chobani was in Shop-Rite before it was in Whole Foods, for some food makers getting a nod from Whole Foods has been a huge step toward mainstream acceptance. Whole Foods' decision seems to imply that small independent producers are still welcome, but those who achieve some level of market saturation--and no longer contribute to Whole Foods' air of artisinally produced goodness--may be asked to leave.