Cost Cutting: The Money Pit
Last autumn, Vivek Wadhwa was scared. Really scared.
Just a few months earlier his company -- Relativity Technologies, in Cary, N.C., which helps businesses update computer systems -- had been soaring at enviable heights. Relativity ended 2000 with $10 million in revenues. Back then, Wadhwa recalls wistfully, "we were anticipating triple-digit percentage growth and double-digit profits." In the first quarter of 2001 he was preparing to take the four-year-old company public before year-end.
But by summer, Relativity was fighting for its life. Recession-panicked customers postponed or canceled scheduled upgrades; between March and mid-July, Relativity didn't close a single new deal. Wadhwa idled 10% of his 175-person workforce and gave everyone else, including himself, pay cuts of 12.5% to 20%.
And it still wasn't enough.
So last fall he started digging through the company's expenditures, mining for potential savings. When he examined the telecom bills, he hit a mother lode: Relativity was spending more than $160,000 annually on voice and data services. Digging further, Wadhwa discovered nugget after nugget of wasted expense. Overseas calls that were billed home at $4.65 a minute. Domestic calls that were billed to a big-name calling card at 18¢ a minute plus a 90¢ "connection fee." And conference-call bills that approached $30,000 a year. Wadhwa characterizes those expenditures as unacceptable even in good times and personally painful in bad ones. "These costs," he reminded employees in a December 2001 memo, "are literally coming out of your salaries as well as mine."
Relativity's experience is far from rare. Total telecom costs -- including charges for phones, cellular services, pagers, toll-free numbers, fax lines, and data communications -- often rank among a company's top five expenses. Per-employee expenditures have doubled since 1996, now averaging $3,000 to $5,000 a year, according to the Aberdeen Group, a Boston-based research and consulting firm, at a time when rates for some telecom services -- such as long-distance and wireless -- have actually dropped by 30% to 50%. Yet many CEOs (40%, according to one International Data Corp. survey) haven't a clue about what their voice and data services actually cost.
Why the disconnect? For some companies, such as Relativity, it was the by-product of a strong economy. "When things were going well, I didn't have time for this," Wadhwa says of his telecom-bill treasure hunts. During the heady dot-com days, he focused on growth rather than cost cutting; in particular, he considered telecom expenses a cost of doing business.
Such ignorance isn't cheap. Gartner Group says companies typically waste 10% of their telecom budgets on outdated services -- old high-rate cellular plans, for instance -- or errors, such as the wrong rates, duplicate bills, incorrect taxes, or inaccurate charges.
One of the more common telecom money pits: unused phone lines. "Let's say you're changing locations," says Tom Heslin, founder of Sunsar Communications, a telecom agency based in Trumbull, Conn. "You order service for the new location, and you order disconnects for the old location, but it never gets disconnected." Or you simply assume your carrier will shut off your old service. Or you transfer employees around your site without moving their telecom services.
In all those cases, the meter may keep running indefinitely. One of Heslin's clients found that it was paying for lines in a building that it had vacated three years earlier. Companies don't always have to eat such losses, however. TelData Control, a telecom consulting and auditing company in East Rutherford, N.J., wrangled a $71,000 refund for a client who for five years had paid for lines that were never turned on.
Another sinkhole: mystery services that companies don't realize they have. Think voice mailboxes for long-departed employees or call waiting on fax lines. Heslin recalls asking one client company about its T1 line. "We've never had one," the staffers replied. "I said, 'Look, it's right here on the bill," Heslin recalls. "The silence in the room was palpable." The line, left by a former occupant, had been live but unused for years, and Heslin's client was paying $500 to $600 a month for it.
How come nobody notices?
Telecom costs often spin out of control as businesses expand. "The more remote sites you have, the uglier it gets," says Aberdeen Group senior analyst Dana Tardelli.
Many small companies that lack full-time telecom managers depend on harried accountants who often pay batch after batch of complex, inch-thick bills without analyzing whether they contain duplicate or inaccurate charges.
Of course, companies can control some telecom expenses by researching their options and negotiating better rates in the first place. (See " Cheap Talk," Inc Technology, 2000, No. 1.) But Wadhwa and other CEOs have found many other ways to cut the high cost of talk.
Go generic. When Relativity employees travel overseas, they now use local prepaid phone cards, allowing them to make international calls that cost the company as little as 7¢ a minute. For domestic calls, Wadhwa has replaced those costly big-name calling cards with a discount warehouse's cards, which charge just 3.5¢ a minute.
Go flat out. Wadhwa cut Relativity's bills by more than 90% when he switched to a teleconferencing service that charges a flat $200-a-month rate. B.Z. Halberstam, CEO of Discus Data Solutions, a New York City-based software-development company, saw his company's monthly cell-phone bills drop 50% after he switched to a fixed-reimbursement plan for each employee.
Cut the cord. Rodger Roeser, president of the Eisen Management Group, in Cleveland, wanted to slash the monthly five-figure long-distance bills at his marketing and public-relations agency. So he cut a deal with a telecom provider and got 30 free cellular phones, each equipped with 700 minutes of nationwide calling for $49.95 a month. Then he instructed his employees to use their new cell phones for all long-distance calls. That switch is saving Eisen $8,000 a month.
Call in the pros. Independent consultants can audit a company's total telecom spending, ferreting out opportunities for savings. QuantumShift, a telecom-management service based in Novato, Calif., audited one small employment agency's telecom records and found 80 unused phone lines and dozens of unassigned voice mailboxes that together were costing the company $1,600 a month.
Consider outsourcing. Some fast-growing companies may find it worthwhile to let somebody else manage the whole telecom mess. DoveBid, a 65-year-old industrial auction house, already had several offices nationwide when it recently either acquired or merged with half a dozen competitors. "We were already getting 10 to 15 bills every month in each location. Then multiply that by the companies we acquired or merged with," says Adam Greenberg, who oversees the company's telecom services. Now the majority of DoveBid's telecom services are consolidated by QuantumShift. For those services (calling cards, cell phones, long-distance lines, and the like), DoveBid is able to run reports using QuantumShift's Web-enabled software. The reports summarize and highlight patterns -- for instance, the company's top five users of cell-phone minutes. Greenberg won't say exactly what DoveBid pays for its QuantumShift services; the company negotiates individual rate packages for each of its customers.
So far, Greenberg also can't say exactly how much DoveBid saves on telecom charges, but he can put a figure on time savings. "It can take one to three hours of three different people's time to process a bill," he says.
Meanwhile, Relativity's Wadhwa credits his telecom savings with helping the company return to profitability. Some of the money he saved he's giving to employees to make up for their pay cuts. But even when things turn around, he'll never again let telecom expenses fall off his personal radar. "I've learned the hard way," he says. The cost-cutting campaign "is something we're going to do from now on. All our profits are going in the bank" -- not to the telecom companies.
Anne Stuart is a senior writer at Inc.
The Whole New Business Catalog
IncQuery: Where Are the Customers?
Redesign: I Read It in the Funny Papers
Hands On: Roadside Assistance
Cost Cutting: The Money Pit
Hands On: Limited Power
Best of the Net: In the Lap of Luxury
Capital: Shell Game
Please E-mail your comments to firstname.lastname@example.org.